Friday, Apr. 12, 2024
Did Fort Worth ISD remove more than 100 books from schools in 2023?
Fort Worth ISD pulled 120 titles from school libraries in August 2023 to review whether they are developmentally appropriate for students.
The district pulled the books before a state law requiring the removal of sexually explicit books from libraries went into effect in September 2023. Portions of the law, House Bill 900, have been on hold as federal courts consider a lawsuit.
The constitutionality of book bans is determined on a case-by-case basis.
The U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1982 that schools cannot remove books because they disagree with the content. However, they can be removed based on appropriateness and curriculum.
The 1982 decision emphasized states have broad authority on education, a topic addressed in all 50 state constitutions but not the U.S. Constitution. State legislators and school boards have final say over what schools teach.
Justice Byron White called book removal “a largely uncharted field.”
This fact brief is responsive to conversations such as this one.
Sources
- Fort Worth Report Fort Worth ISD libraries will reopen Monday. Here’s why
- Fort Worth Report More than 120 books are under review in Fort Worth ISD. Here’s the list
- Fort Worth Report Fort Worth ISD provides no timeline to return pulled books to shelves
- The Free Speech Center When are book bans unconstitutional? A First Amendment scholar explains
- National Constitution Center The First Amendment and school library book policies
- Cornell Board of Education, BOARD OF EDUCATION, ISLAND TREES UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT NO. 26 et al., Petitioners, v. Steven A. PICO, by his next friend Frances Pico et al.
- Cornell John F. TINKER and Mary Beth Tinker, Minors, etc., et al., Petitioners, v. DES MOINES INDEPENDENT COMMUNITY SCHOOL DISTRICT et al.
- US Courts Facts and Case Summary - Tinker v. Des Moines
- The Free Speech Center Board of Education, Island Trees Union Free School District v. Pico (1982)
- First Amendment Museum How Do Books Get Banned?
- U.S. Department of Education Constitutional Obligations for Public Education. 50-State Review, Education Commission of the States, 2016-Mar
About fact briefs
Fact briefs are bite-sized, well-sourced explanations that offer clear "yes" or "no" answers to questions, confusions, and unsupported claims circulating online. They rely on publicly available data and documents, often from the original source. Fact briefs are written and published by Gigafact contributor publications.
See all fact briefs
The Fort Worth Report is a 501(c)(3) organization that launched April 12, 2021. This new media outlet is built on a foundation of local leadership and local investment. It provides community-sourced journalism that exclusively supports and reports on the Fort Worth community with fact-based, thoughtful and contextual coverage without bias or predetermined agendas. The enterprise is governed by a mission statement, bylaws, and an organizational structure that ensures it remains faithful to these foundational principles.
Learn MoreLatest Fact Briefs
Fact brief: Can cities ban panhandling?
Tuesday, Feb. 11, 2025
Fact brief: Did the Texas Lottery start as a way to help fund public schools?
Thursday, Feb. 6, 2025
Fact brief: Do Texas schools track students’ immigration and citizenship status?
Tuesday, Jan. 28, 2025